FROM TECHNOLOGICAL UTOPIANISM TO THE THEORY OF UNEQUAL DEVELOPMENT OF AUTOMATION

Rade Pantić; Rastko Močnik

doi:10.2298/FID250414004P

Authors

Rade Pantić Faculty of Media and Communications, Singidunum University, Belgrade https://orcid.org/0000-0001-7819-9871
Rastko Močnik Faculty of Media and Communications, Singidunum University, Belgrade

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.2298/FID250414004P

Keywords:

automation, unequal development, operaismo, technical composition of labour power, political composition of the working class

Abstract

The article counters popular predictions of a coming “post-work society” with the argument that the capitalist development of technology leads to an uneven introduction of automation into production processes, paralleled by the expansion of wage labour in the service sectors of social reproduction and the circulation of capital in the centre of the capitalist world-system, as well as in labour-intensive production in the periphery. We draw our argument from a critical reading of Italian operaismo whose development we trace in the terms of the sequence “from official Marxisms to a re-interpretation of Capital, from Capital to Grundrisse and back to Capital”. The operaists made an epistemological break in the study of the relationship between the forces and relations of production by identifying the capitalist development of technology as a key site of class struggle. They also introduced a theoretically fruitful distinction between the concepts of the technical composition of labour power and the political
composition of the working class. By introducing the concept of the social composition of labour power, we aim to draw attention to certain negative tendencies within operaismo that led to its vulgarisation by post-operaismo authors, while at the same time correcting it in line with contemporary processes of capital accumulation on a world scale.

References

Bellofiore, Riccardo, and Massimiliano Tomba. 2017. “Afterword.” In: Wright, Steve, ed. Storming Heaven: Class Composition and Struggle in Italian Autonomist Marxism. London: Pluto Press: pp.: 237– 248.

Benanav, Aaron. 2020. Automation and the Future of Work. London: Verso.

Bilić, Paško, Toni Prug, and Mislav Žitko. 2021. The Political Economy of Digital Monopolies. Contradictions and Alternatives to Data Commodification. Bristol: Bristol University Press.

Bologna, Sergio. 1976 [1972]. “Class composition and the theory of the party at the origin of the workers councils movement.” In: CSE, ed. The Labour Process & Class Strategies. London: Stage 1: pp.: 68– 91.

______. 2006 [1976]. “Negri’s Proletarians and the State: A Critique.” In: Murphy, Timothy S., and Abdul-Karim Mustapha, eds. Resistance in Practice. The Philosophy of Antonio Negri. London: Pluto Press: pp.: 38– 47.

Brass, Tom. 2022. “Twisted trajectories, curious chronologies: revisiting the unfree labour debate.” Critical Sociology 48(1): 7–19.

Breznik, Maja. 2023. “Unfree Wage Labour.” Critical Sociology 49 (7-8): 1125– 1139.

______. 2024. “Less or More Labour Law for Social Change?” Industrial Law Journal 53 (4): 613–637.

Brynjolfsson, Erik and Andrew McAfee. 2014. The Second Machine Age: Work, Progress, and Prosperity in a Time of Brilliant Technologies. New York: W. W. Norton & Company.

Caffentzis, George. 1997. “Why Machines Cannot Create Value; or, Marx’s Theory of Machines.” In: Davis, Jim, Thomas Hirschl, and Michael Stack, eds. Cutting Edge: Technology, Information, Capitalism and Social Revolution. London: Verso; pp.: 29–56.

______. 2011. “Immeasurable Value? An Essay on Marx’s Legacy.” In: Lamarche, Pierre, Max Rosenkrantz, and David Sherman, eds. Reading Negri: Marxism in the Age of Empire. Chicago and Lasalle: Open Court: pp.: 101– 125.

______. 2013. In Letters of Blood and Fire: Work, Machines, and the Crisis of Capitalism. Oakland: PM Press.

Camfield, David. 2007. “The Multitude and the Kangaroo: A Critique of Hardt and Negri’s Theory of Immaterial Labour.” Historical Materialism 15 (2): 21–52.

Duménil, Gérard, and Dominique Lévy. 2011. “Unproductive Labour as Profit-Rate-Maximizing Labour.” Rethinking Marxism 23 (2): 216-225.

Hardt, Michael, and Antonio Negri. 2000. Empire. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.

Hassel, Anke. 2014. “The Paradox of Liberalization — Understanding Dualism and the Recovery of the German Political Economy.” British Journal of Industrial Relations 52(1): 57–81.

Heinrich, Michael. 2013. “’The ‘Fragment on Machines’: A Marxian Misconception in the Grundrisse and its Overcoming in Capital.” In: Riccardo Bellofiore et al., eds. In Marx’s Labouratory Critical Interpretations of the Grundrisse. Leiden: Brill: pp.: 195–212.

Jameson, Fredric. 2005. Archaeologies of the Future: The Desire Called Utopia and Other Science Fictions. London: Verso.

Marx, Karl. 1976 [1863–4]. “Appendix: Results of the Immediate Production Process.” In: Capital. A Critique of Political Economy. Volume One. London: Penguin Books: pp.: 941– 1084.

______. 1976 [1867]. Capital. A Critique of Political Economy. Volume One. London: Penguin Books.

______. 1981 [1894]. Capital. A Critique of Political Economy. Volume Three. London: Penguin Books.

______. 1993 [1857–8]. Grundrisse. Foundations of the Critique of Political Economy (Rough Draft). London: Penguin Books.

Močnik, Rastko. 2011. “Tržište radne snage i sastav radničke klase.” In: Popović, Željko and Zoran Gajić (eds.). Kroz tranziciju. Prilozi teoriji privatizacije. Novi Sad: AKO: pp.: 75–106.

Mohun, Simon. 2002. “Productive and Unproductive Labour. Reply to Houston and Laibman.” Review of Radical Political Economics 34 (2): 203–220.

Negri, Toni. 1988 [1982]. “Archaeology and Project. The Mass Worker and the Social Worker.” In: Revolution Retrieved. Writings On Marx, Keynes, Capitalist Crisis, And New Social Subjects (1967-83). London: Red Notes: pp.: 199– 288.

Negri, Antonio. 1991 [1978]. Marx Beyond Marx: Lessons on the Grundrisse. New York- London: Autonomedia-Pluto Press.

Palazzo, David P. 2014.“The ‘Social Factory’ In Postwar Italian Radical Thought From Operaismo To Autonomia.” Ph.D. diss., City University of New York.

Panzieri, Raniero. 1976 [1964]. “Surplus value and planning: Notes on a Reading of Capital.” In: CSE ed. The Labour Process & Class Strategies. London: Stage 1: pp.: 4-25.

______. 1980 [1961]. “The Capitalist Use of Machinery: Marx Versus the Objectivists.” In: Phil Slater ed. Outlines of a Critique of Technology, Atlantic Highlands: Humanities Press: pp.: 44-68.

Pitts, Frederick Harry. 2018. “A Crisis of Measurability? Critiquing Postoperaismo on Labour, Value and the Basic Income.” Capital & Class 42 (1): 3–21.

Prug, Toni and Mislav Žitko. 2023. “Social Forms Beyond Value: Public Wealth and Its Contradictions.” Critical Sociology 50 (4-5): 657-672.

Rifkin, Jeremy. 1995. The End of Work: The Decline of the Global Labour Force and the Dawn of the Post-market Era. New York: Tarcher.

Rigi, Jakob. 2015. “The Demise of the Marxian Law of Value? A Critique of Michael Hardt and Antonio Negri.” In: Fuchs, Christian, and Eran Fisher, eds. Reconsidering Value and Labour in the Digital Age. London: Palgrave Macmillan.

Smith, Jason E. 2020. Smart Machines and Service Work. Automation in an Age of Stagnation. London: Reaktion Books.

______. 2024. “Nowhere to Go: Automation, Then and Now.” In Fehrle, Johannes, Marlon Lieber, and J. Jesse Ramírez, eds. (De)Automating the Future Marxist Perspectives on Capitalism and Technology. Leiden: Bril: pp.: 83– 108.

Smith, John. 2016. Imperialism in the Twenty-First Century: Globalization,

Super-Exploitation, and Capitalism’s Final Crisis. New York: Monthly Review Press.

Solow, Robert. 1987. “We’d Better Watch Out.” New York Times Book Review: 36. URL: http://digamo.free.fr/solow87.pdf (last accessed: January 28, 2025).

Srnicek, Nick and Alex Williams. 2015. Inventing the Future: Postcapitalism and a World Without Work. London: Verso.

Steinhoff, James. 2021. Automation and Autonomy Labour, Capital and Machines in the Artificial Intelligence Industry. Cham: Palgrave Macmillan.

______. 2022. “The Proletarianization of Data Science.” In: Graham, Mark, and Fabian Ferrari, eds. Digital Work in the Planetary Market. Cambridge, Massachusetts: The MIT Press: pp.: 191– 206.

______. 2023. “The industry of automating automation: the political economy of the AI industry.” In: Lindgren, Simon, ed. Handbook of Critical Studies of Artificial Intelligence. Cheltenham-Northampton: Edward Elgar Publishing: pp.: 312– 322.

Steinhoff, James, Atle Mikkola Kjøsen, and Nick Dyer-Witheford. 2024. “Afterword: Stagnation, Circulation, and the Automated Abyss.” In: Fehrle, Johannes, Marlon Lieber, and J. Jesse Ramírez, eds. (De)Automating the Future Marxist Perspectives on Capitalism and Technology. Leiden: Brill: pp.: 288– 310.

Thoburn, Nicholas. 2001. “Autonomous Production? On Negri’s New Synthesis.” Theory, Culture & Society 18 (5): 75–96.

Tomba, Massimiliano, and Riccardo Bellofiore. 2014. “The ‘Fragment on Machines’ and the Grundrisse: The Workerist Reading in Question.” In: Marcel van der Linden, and Karl Heinz Roth, eds. Beyond Marx. Theorising the Global Labour Relations of the Twenty-First Century. Leiden: Brill: pp.: 345– 367.

Trotta, Giuseppe, and Fabio Milana eds. 2008. L’operaismo degli anni Sessanta. Da ‘Quaderni rossi’ a ‘classe operaia’. Roma: DeriveApprodi.

Tronti, Mario. 2019 [1971]. Workers and Capital. London: Verso.

Turchetto, Maria. 2008. “From ‘Mass Worker’ to ‘Empire’: The Disconcerting Trajectory of Italian Operaismo.” In: Bidet, Jacques, and Stathis Kouvelakis, eds. Critical Companion to Contemporary Marxism. Leiden: Brill.

Wright, Steve. 2017. Storming Heaven: Class Composition and Struggle in Italian Autonomist Marxism. London: Pluto Press.