Limits of a Competitive Authoritarianism in Security Policies: Interpreting Türkiye’s Approach towards the EU
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.2298/FID2502479LKeywords:
authoritarianism, European Union, middle power, Türkiye, security policiesAbstract
Middle powers are often states that support and follow democratic principles, demonstrating such atonement in the domestic and foreign policies. However, states that want to emerge in modern multipolarity prefer a more centralised approach, adopting an assertive behaviour against powers or international institutions that criticise alleged ‘authoritarian governance’. Among these countries, Türkiye as a middle power has manifested a growing assertive behaviour towards the European Union (EU) after the failed coup of 2016, capitalizing on such antagonism in the referendum of 2017 has allowed the Justice and Development Party, (Adalet ve Kalkınma Partisi / AKP) to transform Türkiye into a Presidential Republic. Nonetheless, such assertive behaviour in Turkish Foreign Policy (TFP) has not always corresponded to an open antagonism manifested in the domestic rhetoric. In particular, the polarisation of the AKP against the Europeanisation process moved by Turkish presidentialism has shown an inconstant evolution in the security policies. Hence, this article proposes to interpret Turkish presidentialism in its political polarisation and nationalism against the EU in the domestic and foreign policies after the presidential turn. The article contends that Ankara’s leadership, albeit it has evolved the country’s governance into a competitive authoritarian governance, the impact of its security policies towards the EU has not favoured an open assertiveness of Turkish behaviour as a middle power.
References
Akçay, Ümit. 2021. “Authoritarian consolidation dynamics in Turkey.” Contemporary Politics 27 (1): 79–104.
Alpan, Başak, and Ahmet Öztürk. 2022. “Turkish foreign policy in the Balkans amidst ‘soft power’ and ‘de-Europeanisation’.” Southeast European and Black Sea Studies 22 (1): 45–63.
Altinors, Gorkem, and Ümit Akcay. 2022. “Authoritarian neoliberalism, crisis, and consolidation: the political economy of regime change in Turkey.” Globalizations 19: 1–25.
Arısan, Mehmet. 2022. “Populism, victimhood and Turkish foreign policy under AKP rule.” Turkish Studies 23 (5): 681–700.
Arslantaş, Düzgün, and André Kaiser. 2023. “The ‘competitive authoritarian’ turn in Turkey: bandwagoning versus reality.” Third World Quarterly 44 (3): 496–512.
Aydin-Düzgit, Senem. 2018. “Akçay, Ümit. 2021. “Authoritarian consolidation dynamics in Turkey.” Contemporary Politics 27 (1): 79–104.
Alpan, Başak, and Ahmet Öztürk. 2022. “Turkish foreign policy in the Balkans amidst ‘soft power’ and ‘de-Europeanisation’.” Southeast European and Black Sea Studies 22 (1): 45–63.
Altinors, Gorkem, and Ümit Akcay. 2022. “Authoritarian neoliberalism, crisis, and consolidation: the political economy of regime change in Turkey.” Globalizations 19: 1–25.
Arısan, Mehmet. 2022. “Populism, victimhood and Turkish foreign policy under AKP rule.” Turkish Studies 23 (5): 681–700.
Arslantaş, Düzgün, and André Kaiser. 2023. “The ‘competitive authoritarian’ turn in Turkey: bandwagoning versus reality.” Third World Quarterly 44 (3): 496–512.
Aydin-Düzgit, Senem. 2018. “Pesco and Third Countries: Breaking the Deadlock in European Security.” Feuture 3: 1–4.
______. 2023. “Authoritarian Middle Powers and the Liberal Order: Turkey’s Contestation of the EU.” International Affairs 99 (6): 2319–2337.
Aykaç, Pınar. 2022. “Multiple neo-Ottomanisms in the construction of Turkey’s (trans)national heritage: TIKA and a dialectic between foreign and domestic policy.” Turkish Studies 23 (3): 354–382.
Azgın, Bilge. 2020. “The progression and consolidation of erdoğanist authoritarianism in the New Turkey.” Southeast European and Black Sea Studies 20 (2): 371–377.
Besenyő, János and Málnássy, András. 2024. “Geopolitical Dimension of Libyan Drone Warfare: The Use of Turkish Drones on the North African Battlefields.” Obrana a strategie 24 (1): 3–17.
Cagaptay, Soner. 2018. “The New Sultan and the Crisis of Modern Turkey.” The International Spectator 53 (4): 1–15.
Candar, Cengiz. 2019. “The Perennial Kurdish Question and Failed Peace Processes.” In: Özerdem, Alpaslan, and Matthew Whiting, eds. The Routledge Handbook of Turkish Politics. London: Taylor & Francis: pp.: 253–265.
Carney, Josh. 2019. “Projecting ‘New Turkey’ deflecting the coup: squares, screens, and publics at Turkey’s ‘democracy watches’.” Media, Culture & Society 41 (1): 138–148.
Castaldo, Antonio, and Alessandro Pinna. 2019. “After competitive authoritarianism hybrid regime legacies and the quality of democracy in Croatia.” Journal of Contemporary European Studies 27 (4): 486–502.
Castaldo, Antonio. 2018. “Populism and competitive authoritarianism in Turkey.” Southeast European and Black Sea Studies 18 (4): 467–487.
Daily Sabah. 2020. “President Erdoğan calls for joint formula to protect rights of all East Med.” August 10. URL: https://www.dailysabah.com/politics/diplomacy/president-erdogan-calls-for-joint-formula-to-protect-rights-of-all-east-med (last accessed: December 4, 2023).
Dalacoura, Katerina. 2021. “Turkish foreign policy in the Middle East: power projection and post-ideological politics.” International Affairs 97 (4): 1125–1142.
Diamond, Larry, and Marc Plattner. 2015. Democracy in decline? Baltimore: The Johns Hopkins University Press.
Diamond, Larry, Marc Plattner, and Christopher Walker. 2016. Authoritarianism goes global: the challenge to democracy. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press.
Dursun-Özkanca, Oya. 2022. “An examination of the underlying dynamics of Turkey- European Union relations through the lenses of international relations theory.” Turkish Studies 23 (5): 743–764.
EC. 2015. “Key findings of the 2015 report on Turkey”. URL: https://ec.europa.eu/commission/presscorner/detail/en/memo_15_6039 (last accessed: March 14, 2023).
Efstathopoulos, Charalampos. 2018. “Middle Powers and the Behavioural Model.” Global Society 32 (1): 47–69.
EP. 2019. “Turkey’s military operation in Syria and its impact on relations with the EU.” URL: https://www.europarl.europa.eu/EPRS/EPRS-Briefing-642284-Turkeys-military-operation-Syria-FINAL.pdf (last accessed: November 16, 2023).
Esen, Berk, and Sebnem Gumuscu. 2016. “Rising competitive authoritarianism in Turkey.” Third World Quarterly 37 (9): 1581–1606.
______. 2017. “Turkey: How the Coup Failed.” Journal of Democracy 28 (1): 59–73.
Esen, Berk. 2018. “The Perils of ‘Turkish Presidentialism’.” Review of Middle East Studies 52 (1): 43–53.
Glombitza, Olivia. 2021. “The aftermath of Turkey’s July 15th coup attempt: normalizing the exceptional through legitimation, narrativization and ritualization.” Turkish Studies 22 (2): 242–266.
Gokalp Aras, Nefise Ela. 2019. “Coercive Engineered Syrian Mass Migration in the EU-Turkey Relations: A Case Analysis for Future Reference.” International Migration 57 (2): 186–199.
Grzywacz, Anna, and Marcin Florian Gawrycki. 2021. “The authoritarian turn of middle powers: changes in narratives and engagement.” Third World Quarterly 42 (11): 2629–2650.
Gümüş, Abdurrahman. 2022. “Increasing Realism in Turkish Foreign Policy during Post-Davutoğlu Era.” Insight Turkey 24 (4): 167–186.
Haugom, Lars. 2019. “Turkish Foreign Policy under Erdogan: A Change in International Orientation?” Comparative Strategy 38 (3): 206–223.
Jaffrey, Sana, and Eve Warburton. 2024. “On the Edge of Competitive Authoritarianism.” Bulletin of Indonesian Economic Studies 60 (3): 283–304.
Jeong, Monica. 2019. “Critical realism: A better way to think about middle powers.” International Journal 74 (2): 240–257.
Jongerden, Joost. 2019. “Conquering the State and Subordinating Society Under AKP Rule: A Kurdish Perspective on the Development of a New Autocracy in Turkey.” Journal of Balkan and Near Eastern Studies 21 (30): 260–273.
Jordaan, Edouard. 2003. “The concept of a middle power in international relations: distinguishing between emerging and traditional middle powers.” Politikon 30 (1): 165–181.
Kaliber, Alper, Esra Kaliber. 2019. “From De-Europeanisation to AntiWestern Populism: Turkish Foreign Policy in Flux.” The International Spectator 54 (4): 1–16.
Kfir, Isaac. 2018. “A Faustian pact: Has the EU-Turkey deal undermined the EU’s own security?” Comparative Strategy 37 (3): 207–219.
Kinik, Hülya, and Sinem Çelik. 2021. “The Role of Turkish Drones in Azerbaijan’s Increasing Military Effectiveness: An Assessment of the Second Nagorno- Karabakh War.” Insight Turkey 23 (4): 169–191.
Kleinfeld, Rachel, Thomas Carothers, Steven Feldstein, and Richard Youngs. 2021. “How Middle-Power Democracies Can Help Renovate Global Democracy Support.” Carnegie, February 4. URL: https://carnegieendowment.org/research/2021/02/how-middle-power-democracies-can-help-renovate-global-democracy-support?lang=en (last accessed: January 13, 2024).
Koçak, Muhammet, and Musa Akgül. 2022. “Quest for regional power status: Explaining Turkey’s assertive foreign policy.” International Journal 77 (2): 292–312.
Kuşku-Sönmez, Eda. 2024. “Turkey and the EU: waning foreign policy alignment in a changing international context.” Southeast European and Black Sea Studies: 1–19.
Kutlay, Mustafa, and Ziya Öniş. 2021. “Understanding oscillations in Turkish foreign policy: pathways to unusualmiddle power activism.” Third World Quarterly 42 (12): 3051–3069.
Levitsky, Steven, and Lucan Way. 2002. “Elections without democracy: the rise of competitive authoritarianism.” Journal of Democracy 13 (2): 51–65.
Müftüler-Baç, Meltem. 2016. “The Pandora’s box: Democratization and rule of law in Turkey.” Asia Europe Journal 14 (1): 61–77.
Murariu, Mihai, and George Anglițoiu. 2020. “Anatolian Security and Neo- Ottomanism: Turkey’s Intervention in Syria.” Middle East Policy 27 (2): 112–147.
Oğuzlu, H. Tarık. 2023. “Turkey as a restrained middle power.” Turkish Studies 24 (3–4): 673–690.
Öniş, Ziya. 2023. “Historic missed opportunities and prospects for renewal: Turkey- EU relations in a post-Western order.” Turkish Studies 24 (3–4): 691–713.
Parlar Dal, Emel. 2019. “Status-seeking policies of middle powers in status clubs: the case of Turkey in the G20.” Contemporary Politics 25 (5): 586–602.
Resch, E. Maria. 2017. “Syria’s Impact on the Kurdish Peace Process in Turkey.” Istituto Affari Internazionali Working Papers 17: 1–20.
Somer, Murat. 2019. “Turkey: The Slippery Slope from Reformist to Revolutionary Polarization and Democratic Breakdown.” The Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science 681 (1): 42–61.
Soyaltin-Colella, Digdem, and Tolga Demiryol. 2023. “Unusual middle power activism and regime survival: Turkey’s drone warfare and its regime-boosting effects.” Third World Quarterly 44 (4): 724–743.
Sucu, Ali Emre et al. 2021. “Transformation of Middle Powers with the Decline of World Hegemony: The Case of Turkey.” Strategic Analysis 45 (4): 307–320.
Taş, Hakkı. 2020. “The formulation and implementation of populist foreign policy: Turkey in the Eastern Mediterranean.” Mediterranean Politics 27 (5): 563–587.
Thevenin, Elodie. 2021. “Between human rights and security concerns: politicisation of EU-Turkey and EU-Libya agreements on migration in national parliaments.” European Security 30 (3): 464–484.
TMFA. 2014. “No: 82, 12 March 2014, Press Release Regarding the European Parliament Resolution on the European Commission’s 2013 Progress Report on Turkey”. URL: https://www.mfa.gov.tr/no_-82_-12-march-2014_-press-release-regarding-the-european-parliament-resolution-on-the-european-commission_s-2013-progress-r.en.mfa (last accessed August 24, 2023).
TMFA. 2015. “The 53rd Meeting of the Turkey-EU Association Council was held in Brussels”. URL: https://www.mfa.gov.tr/the-53rd-meeting-of-the-turkey_eu-association-council-was-held-in-brussels.en.mfa (last accessed: October 17, 2023).
TMFA. 2018. “Article by H.E. Mr. Mevlüt Çavuşoğlu published in Foreign Policy titled “The Meaning of Operation Olive Branch”, 5 April 2018.” URL: https://www.mfa.gov.tr/article-by-h_e_-mr_-mevlut-cavusoglu_-the-minister-of-foreign-affairs-of-turkey-the-_meaning_-of-operation-olive-branch.en.mfa (last accessed: September 10, 2023).
TMFA. 2019. “No: 297, 11 October 2019, Press Release Regarding Certain Comments in the International Community on Operation Peace Spring.” URL: https://www.mfa.gov.tr/no_297_-baris-pinari-harekati-ni-hedef-alan-yorumlar-hk.en.mfa (last accessed: September 11, 2023).
TMFA. 2022. “No: 62, 24 February 2022, Press Release Regarding the Russian Federation’s Military Operation Against Ukraine.” URL: https://www.mfa.gov.tr/no_-62_-rusya-federasyonu-tarafindan-ukrayna-ya-yonelik-baslatilan-askeri-operasyon-hk.en.mfa (last accessed: September 9, 2023).
TMFA. 2023. “No: 245, 5 October 2023, Press Release Regarding the Resolution Titled “On the Situation in ‘Nagorno-Karabakh’ after Azerbaijan’s Attack and the Continuing Threats Against Armenia” Adopted by the European Parliament.” URL: https://www.mfa.gov.tr/no_-245_-_avrupa-parlamentosu-nun-kabul-ettigi--karar-hk.en.mfa (last accessed: December 4, 2023).
Tüysüzoğlu, Göktürk. 2024. “The Analysis of the Connection Between the Authoritarian Regime and Eurasianism: The Case of Turkey.” Asian Journal of Middle Eastern and Islamic Studies: 1–26.
Tziarras, Zenonas. 2018. “Erdoğanist authoritarianism and the ‘new’ Turkey.” Southeast European and Black Sea Studies 18 (4): 593–598.
Ugur-Cinar, Meral. 2023. “Elections and Democracy in Turkey: Reconsidering Competitive Authoritarianism in the Age of Democratic Backsliding.” The Political Quarterly 94 (3): 445–451.
Ülgül, Murat, and Sertif Demir. 2020. “Keeping the Soldiers at Bay: Coup-Proofing Strategies in Turkey.” Middle East Policy 27 (3): 138–151.
Umut, Aydın. 2021. “Emerging middle powers and the liberal international order.” International Affairs 97 (5): 1377–1394.
Uzgell, Ilhan. 2022. “Turkish Foreign Policy After Presidentialism.” Middle East Institute, October 25. URL: https://www.mei.edu/publications/turkish-foreign-policy-after-presidentialism (last accessed: January 13, 2024).
Wastnidge, Edward. 2019. “Imperial Grandeur and Selective Memory: Reassessing Neo-Ottomanism in Turkish Foreign and Domestic Politics.” Middle East Critique 28 (1): 7–28.
Yilmaz Ihsan, Mustafa Demir, and Erdoan Shipoli. 2022. “Securitisation via functional actors and authoritarian resilience: collapse of the Kurdish peace process in Turkey.” Australian Journal of Political Science 57 (1): 1–16.
Yilmaz Ihsan, Erdoan Shipoli, and Mustafa Demir. 2021. “Authoritarian resilience through securitization: an Islamist populist party’s co-optation of a secularist farright party.” Democratization 28 (6): 1115–1132.
Yilmaz, Ihsan, and Galib Bashirov. 2018. “The AKP after 15 Years: Emergence of Erdoganism in Turkey.” Third World Quarterly 39 (9): 1812–1830.
Yılmaz, Zafer, and S. Bryan Turner. 2019. “Turkey’s deepening authoritarianism and the fall of electoral democracy.” British Journal of Middle Eastern Studies 46 (5): 691–698.
Yüksel, Engin. 2020. “Turkey’s approach to proxy war in the Middle East and North Africa.” Security and Defence Quarterly 31 (4): 137–152.
Downloads
Published
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2025 Filozofija i društvo/Philosophy and Society
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.
Articles published in Philosophy and Society are open-access in accordance with the CC BY-NC-ND 4.0 License.
How to Cite
