Ennahda’s Muslim Democracy in Post-Arab Spring Tunisia: Synthesizing Political Thought and Practice
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.2298/FID2403515AKljučne reči:
Ennahda, political Islam, Muslim democracy, functional specialization, re- authoritarianism, organizational reformationApstrakt
This article explores the interplay between political thought and practice within Tunisia’s Ennahda party, first during its period in opposition, then after it took power in 2011, and finally in the aftermath of the 2021 coup. We trace the genealogy of political thought within the party from the point of its foundation. In doing so, we explore the gradual evolution of party ideology, from a daʿwa-based belief system between 1969 and 1981, to Islamic democracy between 1981 and 2011, to ‘Muslim democracy’ after the 2011 uprising. We examine this ideological evolution through the framework of three key elements: (i) Islam, (ii) Tunisia’s changing socio-political context, and (iii) the broader universal episteme. As we show, a significant turning point came in 2016, with the separation of the daʿwa from party politics, which revealed a burgeoning state / party conceptualization of politics. However, the 2021 coup challenged Ennahda’s concept of Muslim democracy, as well as all aspects of the party’s own sense of continuity as a significant socio-political actor, such as its institutional structure, leadership, membership, social base, political strategy, and ideology. Ennahda is now confronted by an authoritarian resurgence, which aims at containing the party, and at delegitimizing its participation within nation-state structures. Empirical evidence, based on content-analytical evaluations of personal interviews as well as the media’s coverage of Ennahda, shows that the party’s representatives are increasingly focusing on organizational reform in order to deal with the ramifications of the 2021 coup. Their aim seems to be to democratize both Ennahda and the Tunisian state itself.
Reference
Al-Amdouni, Loutfi. 2015. The Islamic Movement in Tunisia: 1965–1981. Tunis: Dar al-Arqam.
Al-Jazeera. 2023. “Three dissidents go on a hunger strike to protest their pris conditions.” URL: https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2023/6/13/three-tunisian- opposition-leaders-on-hunger-strike-in-prison (last accessed: August 24, 2024).
Al-Tunisi, Khayr al-Din. 1987. Aqwam al-Masālik fi Maʿrifat Aḥwāl al-Mamālik [The Surest Path to Knowing the Condition of Kingdoms]. Tunis: Matba’at al-dawlah.
Ben Achour, Rafaâ. 2022. Tunisie: le retour au pouvoir autocratique. Revue Française de Droit Constitutionnel 132 (4): 1001–1018.
Ben Hamadi, Monia. 2023. “In Tunisia, Ennahda’s Protracted Downward Spiral.” Le Monde Africa, April 27. URL: https://www.lemonde.fr/en/le-monde- africa/article/2023/04/27/in-tunisia-ennahda-s-protracted-downward- spiral_6024601_124.html (last accessed: August 24, 2024).
Ben Nabi, Malek. 1966. Introduction to the Sociology of Islam. London: Garnet Publishing.
Ben Nabi, Malek. 1954. Islam in History and Society. Cambridge: The Islamic Foundation.
Brahem, Sami. 2024. “Transformations of “Political Islam” in Tunisia through Evaluating Primary Documents.” Al Jazeerah Centre for Studies, March 12. URL: https://studies.aljazeera.net/ar/article/5870 (last accessed: August 24, 2024).
Brahem, Sami. 2024. Personal Interview. Tunis, February 19.
Brayik, Hadi. 2013. Ennahda Movement from Dawa to Authority. Deutschland.
Brésillon, Thierry. 2020. “Ennahda, the ‘Sick Man’ of Tunisian Politics.” Orient XXI, February 13.
. 2021. “Ennahda or the cost of recognition.” Arab Reform Initiative, November 26.
. 2021. “Tunisia: Inevitable Upheaval Fraught with Dangers.” Orient XXI, August 9.
Business News. 2022. “‘Abdellatif Mekki Annonce la Formation d’un Nouveau Parti Politique’.” Business News, May 1. URL: https://www.businessnews. com.tn/abdellatif-mekki-annonce-la-formation-dun-nouveau-parti- politique,520,118785,3. (last accessed: August 24, 2024).
Chaib, Riad. 2024. Personal Interview. Tunis, February 25.
Dihstelhoff, Julius, and Moritz Simon. 2024. “Power Sharing Processes in Post-Arab Spring Tunisia: From Elite Compromise to Presidential Monopolization.” In: Allison McCulloch, Sören Keil, and Eduardo Aboultaif, eds. Power-Sharing in the Global South: Patterns, Practices and Potential. Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan: pp.: 123–145.
Dihstelhoff, Julius, and Mounir Mrad. 2022. “Eine Neue Verfassung für Tunesien? Es Droht ein Autoritärer Drift!.” F.A.Z. Einspruch, July 18. URL: https://www.faz. net/einspruch/eine-neue-verfassung-fuer-tunesien-es-droht-ein-autoritaerer- drift-18181646.html (last accessed: August 24, 2024).
–––––––. 2023. “Tunesiens undemokratisches Wahlgesetz.” F.A.Z. Einspruch, January 27. https://www.faz.net/einspruch/eine-neue-verfassung-fuer- tunesien-es-droht-ein-autoritaerer-drift-18181646.html (last accessed: August 24, 2024).
––––––. 2023. “Kais Saied’s Reconfiguration of Tunisia’s Political System: Hegemonic Ambitions to no Avail? – A critical Approach.” L’Année du Maghreb, 30. URL: https://www.faz.net/einspruch/das-ende-des-arabischen-fruehlings- tunesiens-undemokratisches-wahlgesetz-18636039.html (last accessed: August 24, 2024).
El-Khawas, Mohamed A. 1996. “Revolutionary Islam in North Africa: Challenges and Responses.” Africa Today 43 (4): 385–404.
Ennahda Movement. 1996. “Bianat Dhikra al-Tasis, Qutouf al-Maarifa”, 15th Anniversary leaflet 57–90. London, June 6.
–––––––. 2010. “Bylaws of the 10th Conference.” Tunis: Hammamet, May 20–22.
–––––––. 1981. “The Founding Carta of the Islamic Tendence Movement.” Tunis, June 6. In: ‘Bianat Dhikra al-Tasisi, Qutouf al-Maarifa’, 2012.
Ennahdha Media. 2021a. “Ennahdha Consultative Council Statement Following 52nd Meeting Tunis.” Ennahdha Media, August 5.
–––––––. 2021b. “Ennahdha Party Statement Following President Seizing Tunisia’s Democratic Powers, Tunis.” Ennahdha Media. Tunis, July 31.
–––––––. 2021c. “Press release from the Muslim Democratic Ennahdha Party on recent events in Tunisia, Tunis.” Ennahdha Media. Tunis, July 26.
Ennahda Party. 2021. “Ennahdha-Partei Newsletter Ausgabe 81.” Tunis, August 19. Esposito, John L., ed. 1997. Political Islam: Revolution, Radicalism, or Reform?. Boulder, CO: Lynne Rienner Publishers.
Ghannouchi, Rachid. 2022. Public Freedoms in the Islamic State (trans.: World Thought). New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.
–––––––. 2015. From the Experience of The Islamic Movement in Tunisia, 2nd Ed. Beirut: The Mojtahed publishing House.
–––––––. 2015. Signs of the Revolution. Tunis: Almujtahed Publications.
–––––––. 2016.”From Political Islam to Muslim Democracy: The Ennahda Party and the Future of Tunisia.” Foreign Affairs 95 (5): 58–67.
Guesmi, Haythem. 2022. “Ennahdha Needs to Change to Save itself, and Tunisia’s Democracy.” Aljazeera, August 13.
Human Rights Watch. 5 May 2023a. “La Tunisie persiste et signe dans le recul de la démocratie.”
–––––––. 11 May 2023b. “Tunisie: Les autorités démantèlent le plus important parti d’opposition du pays.”
Ibn Khaldoun, Abdel Rahman. 2004. Kitāb al-ʿIbar we Diwān al-Mubtadaʿ wa al- Khabar. vol. 1. Damascus: Dar Uraib.
Anonymous Party Leader. 2024. Personal Interview. Sfax, January 16.
Madhoub, Maher. 2023. Personal Interview. Tunis, July 22.
Khayr al-Din al-Tunisi. 1987. ʾAqwam al-Masālik fi Maʿrifat Aḥwāl al-Mamālik. Tunis: Matba’at al-dawlah.
Kirkpatrick, David D. 2011. “Moderate Islamist Party Heads Toward Victory in Tunisia.” The New York Times, October 24.
Lourimi, Ajmi. 2024. “Changing the name of Al-Nahda is possible, and this has been proposed within the Content Preparation Committee.” Facebook (last accessed: April 22, 2024).
Lynch, Mark. 2024. “The Future of Islamism through the Lens of the Past.” Journal Religions Special Issue Islamist Movements in the Middle East 13 (113), https:// doi.org/10.3390/rel13020113.
March, Andrew, and Rached Ghannouchi. 2023. On Muslim Democracy: Essays and Dialogues. New York, NY: Oxford University Press.
McCarthy, Rory. 2024. “Between Authoritarian Crack-Down and Internal Crisis, Can Ennahda Rise Again?.” Nawaat, April 10.
Murphy, Emma C. 1999a. Economic and Political Change in Tunisia: From Bourguiba to Ben Ali. Palgrave Macmillan.
Murphy, Emma C. 1999b. “The Rise and Fall of the Corporatist State in Tunisia, 1956–1986.” In: Economic and Political change in Tunisia. London: Palgrave Macmillan: pp.: 42–79.
Nafti, Hatem. 2023. “Le système de Kaïs Saïed: un projet populiste autoritaire porté avec le concours des élites.” Confluences Méditerranée 2 (125): 27–40.
Ouaissa, Rachid et al. “Islamismus-Begriff.” CNMS Islamismus. URL: https://www. uni-marburg.de/de/cnms/politik/forschung/cnms-islamismus/grundlagen/ (last accessed: August 24, 2024).
Patel, David Siddhartha. 2022. “Ennahda: Before and After the Coup in Tunisia.” Interview with Andrew F. March, Massachusetts: Brandeis University, 8. July 2022.
–––––. “The Tunisian Public and the Rise of Kais Saied A Conversation with Hind Ahmed Zaki.” Brandeis University. URL: https://www.brandeis.edu/crown/ publications/crown-conversations/cc-13.html (last accessed: August 24, 2024).
Présidence de la Tunisie. 2022. “Meeting of the President of the Republic, Kais Saied, with Mr. Samir Saied, Minister of Economy and Planning.” Facebook, December 2. URL: https://www.facebook.com/Presidence.tn/ videos/2300170413477906/ (last accessed, August 24, 2024).
––––––. 2023. “Meeting of the President of the Republic, Kais Saied, with Ms. Kulthum Ben Rajab, Minister of Trade and Development.” Facebook. URL: https://www.facebook.com/watch/?v=51871670037376 (last accessed, August 24, 2024).
––––––. 2023. “Kais Saied to Al Arabiya: We will hold accountable everyone who committed crimes against Tunisians.” YouTube, July 26. URL: https://www. youtube.com/watch?v=sz1NaBvpqSA&list=WL&index=7 (last accessed, August 24, 2024).
––––––. 2024. “Today, Monday, April 15, 2024, the President of the Republic, Kais Saied, supervised the meeting of the National Security Council.” YouTube, April
URL: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sz1NaBvpqSA (last accessed, August 24, 2024).
Qaradawi, Youssef. 2008. dirāsa fi fiqh maqāṣid al-sharīʿa [A Study of Goals of Sharia], 3rd Ed. Cairo: Dar al-Shorouk.
Qutb, Sayyid. 1949. Al-Adala al-Ijtima’iyya fi-l-Islam [Social Justice in Islam]. Cairo: Dar Al-Kateb Al-’Arabi.
–––––. 1987. Milestones (ed.:A. B. al-Mehri). Egypt: Dar Al Shorouk.
–––––. 2004. Nāḥwa mujtamaʿ ʾislami [Toward a Muslim Society]. Egypt: Dar Al Shorouk.
Roy, Olivier. 1998. The Failure of Political Islam [Tans. Carol Volk]. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
Sadiki, Larbi. 2020. “Intra-Party Democracy in Tunisia’s Ennahda: Ghannouchi and the Pitfalls of ‘Charismatic’ Leadership.” Middle East Institute, November 25.
–––––. 2021. “Tunisia’s Ennahdha is at a crossroads.” Aljazeera, August 9.
Sfeir, George N., 1957. “The Tunisian Code of Personal Status.” Middle East Journal 11 (3): 309–318.
Shaib, Riad. 2013. Political Thought Debate: De-constructivist Vision of the Islamic Movement. Tunis: Sotepa Graphic.
Tamimi, Azzam. 2001. Rachid Ghannouchi: A Democrat within Islamism. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Thielicke, Valerian. 2021. Zwischen Laïcité und Theokratie: Der Konflikt zwischen Islamist:innen und Säkularen in Tunesien. Berlin: Springer.
Thyen, Kressen, and Maria Josua. 2023. “Tunesiens Präsident Kais Saied: vom Hoffnungsträger zum Autokraten.” URL: https://doi.org/10.57671/gfme-23041 (last accessed: August 24, 2024).
Yerkes, Sarah. 2022. “Tunisia and the Future of Political Islam.” Wilson Center, August 17.
##submission.downloads##
Objavljeno
Kako citirati
Broj časopisa
Sekcija
Licenca
Sva prava zadržana (c) 2024 Filozofija i društvo/Philosophy and Society
Ovaj rad je pod Creative Commons Aуторство-Nekomercijalno-Bez prerade 4.0 Internacionalna licenca.
Articles published in Philosophy and Society are open-access in accordance with the CC BY-NC-ND 4.0 License.