Relationship between Moral Responsibility for Zoonotic Pandemics Outbreaks and Industrial Animal Farms

Josip Guć

doi:10.2298/FID2104695G

Autori

Josip Guć University of Split, Faculty of Humanities and Social Sciences, Centre for Integrative Bioethics

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.2298/FID2104695G

Ključne reči:

moral responsibility, animals, pandemics, COVID-19, industrial farms, global capitalism

Apstrakt

The responsibility for the COVID-19 pandemic was first ascribed to persons associated with the Huanan Seafood Market. However, many scientists suggest that this pandemic is actually a consequence of human intrusion into nature. This opens up a whole new perspective for an examination of direct and indirect, individual and collective responsibility concerning this particular pandemic, but also zoonotic pandemics as such. In this context, one of the key issues are the consequences of factory-farming of animals, which contributes to circumstances in which zoonotic pandemics emerge. Moreover, it is part of a larger economic system, global capitalism, whose logic implies certain coercion toward its participants to keep it essentially unchanged and therefore to make sure that livestock health remains “the weakest link in our global health chain” (FAO). However, even though the precise answer to the issue of moral responsibility for zoonotic pandemics outbreaks in general and the COVID-19 pandemic in particular cannot be given, it is possible to list certain indicators and make a framework helpful in ascribing moral responsibility to certain persons. The paper intends to do so by examining the notion of responsibility and by applying it to the issues mentioned. The results of this analysis show that it is misleading to place moral blame on people involved in actions that directly caused the animal-to-human transmission of a certain virus or on humanity as a whole.

Reference

Afelt, Aneta; Frutos, Roger; Devaux, Christian (2018), “Bats, Coronaviruses, and Deforestation: Toward the Emergence of Novel Infectious Diseases?”, Frontiers in Microbiology 9: 702.

Anthis, Kelly (2019), “Global Farmed & Factory Farmed Animals Estimates”, Sentience Institute, last updated 21 February 2019. https://www.sentienceinstitute.org/global-animal-farming-estimates

Barona, Elizabeth; Ramankutty, Navin; Hyman, Glen; Coomes, Oliver T. (2010), “The Role of Pasture and Soybean in Deforestation of the Brazilian Amazon”, Environmental Research Letters 5 (2):024002.

Burkett, Paul (2003), “Capitalism, Nature, and the Class Struggle”, in Alfredo Saad-Filho (ed.), Anti-Capitalism: A Marxist Introduction, London, Sterling, VA: Pluto Press, pp. 106–116.

CDC (2021), “Animals & COVID-19 (Updated Jan. 19, 2021)”, CDC: Center for Disease Control and Prevention. https://www.cdc.gov/coronavirus/2019-ncov/daily-life-coping/animals.html

Cohen, Jon (2020), “Wuhan Seafood Market May Not Be Source of Novel Virus Spreading Globally”, Science, 26 January.

Contini, Carlo; Di Nuzzo, Mariachiara; Barp, Nicole; Bonazza, Aurora; De Giorgio, Roberto; Tognon, Mauro; Rubino Salvatore (2020), “The Novel Zoonotic COVID-19 Pandemic: An Expected Global Health Concern”, The Journal of Infection in Developing Countries 14 (3): 254–264.

Drexler, Madeline (2002), Secret Agents: The Menace of Emerging Infections, Washington, D.C.: Joseph Henry Press.

Dunne, Daisy (2020), “Q&A: Could Climate Change and Biodiversity Loss Raise the Risk of Pandemics?”, Carbon Brief, 15 May. https://www.carbonbrief.org/q-and-a-could-climate-change-and-biodiversity-loss-raise-the-risk-of-pandemics

Ellul, Jacques (1992), “The Betrayal by Technology: A Portrait of Jacques Ellul” [interview by Jan van Boeckel and Karin van der Molen]. http://www.naturearteducation.org/R/Artikelen/Betrayal.htm

FAO (2013), World Livestock 2013: Changing Disease Landscapes, Rome: Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations. http://www.fao.org/3/i3440e/i3440e.pdf

Fiala, Nathan (2008), “Meeting the Demand: An Estimation of Potential Future Greenhouse Gas Emissions from Meat Production”, Ecological Economics 67 (3): 412–419.

Foer, Jonathan Safran (2009), Eating Animals, New York, Boston, London: Back Bay Books, Little, Brown and Company.

Foster, John Bellamy; Clark, Brett (2020), The Robbery of Nature: Capitalism and the Ecological Rift, New York: Monthly Review Press.

GRAIN (2020), “New Research Suggests Industrial Livestock, not Wet Markets, Might Be Origin of Covid-19”, GRAIN, 30 March. https://www.grain.org/en/article/6437-new-research-suggests-industrial-livestock-not-wet-markets-might-be-origin-of-covid-19#sdfootnote5anc

Guć, Josip (2019), „Samoostvarivanje živih bića i genetički modificirani organizmi u poljoprivredi“, Jahr 10 (2): 361–375.

Gunderson, Ryan (2011), “From Cattle to Capital: Exchange Value, Animal Commodification, and Barbarism”, Critical Sociology 39 (2): 259–275.

Hart, Herbert Lionel Adolphus (2008), Punishment and Responsibility: Essays in the Philosophy of Law (2nd ed.), New York: Oxford University Press.

Höffe, Otfried (1997), „Verantwortung“, in Otfried Höffe (ed.), Lexikon der Ethik (5th ed.). München: C. H. Beck, pp. 314–316.

Horkheimer, Max; Adorno, Theodor (2002), Dialectic of Enlightenment: Philosophical Fragments, Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press.

Huang, Chaolin; Yeming Wang; Xingwang Li; Lili Ren; Jianping Zhao; Yi Hu; Li Zhang; Guohui Fan; Jiuyang Xu; Xiaoying Gu; Zhenshun Cheng; Ting Yu, Jiaan Xia; Yuan Wei; Wenjuan Wu; Xuelei Xie; Wen Yin; Hui Li; Min Liu; Yan Xiao; Hong Gao; Li Guo; Jungang Xie; Guangfa Wang; Rongmeng Jiang; Zhancheng Gao; Qi Jin; Jianwei Wang; Bin Cao (2020), “Clinical Features of Patients Infected with 2019 Novel Coronavirus in Wuhan, China”, Lancet 395: 497–506.

IACG (2019), No Time to Wait: Securing the Future from Drug-Resistant Infections. Report to the Secretary-General of the United Nations, IACG: Interagency Coordination Group on Antimicrobial Resistance. https://www.who.int/antimicrobial-resistance/interagency-coordination-group/IACG_final_report_EN.pdf?ua=1&utm_source=newsletter&utm_medium=email&utm_campaign=newsletter_axiosscience&stream=science

IPBES (2020), Workshop Report on Biodiversity and Pandemics of the Intergovernmental Platform on Biodiversity and Ecosystem Services, Bonn: IPBES secretariat.

Johnson, Christine K.; Hitchens, Peta L.; Pandit, Pranav S.; Rushmore, Julie; Evans, Tierra Smiley; Young, Cristin C. W.; Doyle, Megan M. (2020), “Global Shifts in Mammalian Population Trends Reveal Key Predictors of Virus Spillover Risk”, Proceedings of the Royal Society B 287: article 20192736.

Jonas, Hans (1984), The Imperative of Responsibility: In Search of an Ethics for the Technological Age, Chicago, London: The University of Chicago Press.

Kovel, Joel (2007), The Enemy of Nature: The End of Capitalism or the End of Nature, London, New York, Halifax, Winnipeg: Zed Books, Fernwood Publishing.

LEAD: The Livestock, Environment and Development (2006), Livestock’s Long Shadow: Environmental Issues and Options, Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations. http://www.fao.org/3/a-a0701e.pdf

Lucey, Daniel (2020), “UPDATE Wuhan Coronavirus – 2019-nCoV Q&A #6: An Evidence-based Hypothesis” [interview by unnamed author], Science Speaks: Global ID News, 25 January. https://sciencespeaksblog.org/2020/01/25/wuhan-coronavirus-2019-ncov-qa-6-an-evidence-based-hypothesis/

Malm, Andreas (2018), Fosilni kapital: uspon parnoga pogona i korijeni globalnog zatopljenja, Zaprešić, Zagreb: Fraktura, Institut za političku ekologiju.

Marchant-Forde, Jeremy N.; Boyle, Laura A., “COVID-19 Effects on Livestock Production: A One Welfare Issue”, Frontiers in Veterinary Science 7:585787.

Marx, Karl (1973), Grundrisse: Introduction to the Critique of Political Economy, New York: Random House.

McMullen, Steven (2015), “Is Capitalism to Blame? Animal Lives in the Marketplace”, Journal of Animal Ethics 5 (2): 126–134.

OECD & FAO (2018), OECD-FAO Agricultural Outlook 2018-2027, Paris, London: OECD Publishing, Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations.

OIE (2020), “Infection with SARS-CoV-2 in Animals”, OIE: World Organisation for Animal Health. https://www.oie.int/fileadmin/Home/MM/EN_Factsheet_SARS-CoV-2_v8_final.pdf

Quammen, David (2020), “We Made the Coronavirus Epidemic”, The New York Times 28 January, https://www.nytimes.com/2020/01/28/opinion/coronavirus-china.html?smtyp=cur&smid=tw-nytopinion

Qiu, Ye; Yuan-Bo Zhao; Qiong Wang, Jin-Yan Li; Zhi-Jian Zhou; Ce-Heng Liao; Xing-Yi Ge (2020), “Predicting the Angiotensin Converting Enzyme 2 (ACE2) Utilizing Capability as the Receptor of SARS-CoV-2” [in press], Microbes and infections.

Sebo, Jeff; Stubler, Nico (2020), “To Reduce the Risk of Pandemics, We Must Ban Factory Farms Now”, Sentient Media, 7 April. https://sentientmedia.org/to-reduce-the-risk-of-pandemics-we-must-ban-factory-farms-now/

Scott-Reid, Jessica (2020a), “Farmed Animals Culled En Masse as COVID-19 Outbreaks Halt Meat and Dairy Production”, Sentient Media, 29 April.

https://sentientmedia.org/farmed-animals-culled-en-mass-as-covid-19-outbreaks-halt-meat-and-dairy-production/

—. (2020b), “When Gassing Animals to Death Doesn’t Work”, Sentient Media, 28 July. https://sentientmedia.org/when-gassing-animals-to-death-doesnt-work/

Spinney, Laura (2020), “Is Factory Farming to Blame for Coronavirus?”, The Guardian, 28 March. https://www.theguardian.com/world/2020/mar/28/is-factory-farming-to-blame-for-coronavirus

Subak, Susan (1999), “Global Environmental Cost of Beef Production”, Ecological Economics 30 (1): 79–91.

Van Beusekom, Mary (2020), “COVID-19 Likely Spreading from People to Animals

– and Vice Versa”, CIDRAP: Center for Infectious Disease Research and Policy, University of Minnesota, September 18. https://www.cidrap.umn.edu/news-perspective/2020/09/covid-19-likely-spreading-people-animals-and-vice-versa

Vidal, John (2020), “‘Tip of the Iceberg’: Is Our Destruction of Nature Responsible for Covid-19?”, The Guardian, 18 March. https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2020/mar/18/tip-of-the-iceberg-is-our-destruction-of-nature-responsible-for-covid-19-aoe

Wallace, Rob (2016), Big Farms Make Big Flu: Dispatches on Influenza, Agribusiness, and the Nature of Science, New York: Monthly Review Press.

—. (2020), Dead Epidemiologists: On the Origins of COVID-19, New York: Monthly Review Press.

Wallace, Rob; Wallace, Deborah (2020), “To the Bat Cave”, in Rob Wallace, Dead Epidemiologists: On the Origins of COVID-19, New York: Monthly Review Press, pp. 157–175.

Wallace, Rob; Liebman, Alex; Chaves, Luis Fernando; Wallace, Rodrick (2020a), “COVID-19 and Circuits of Capital”, in Rob Wallace, Dead Epidemiologists:

On the Origins of COVID-19, New York: Monthly Review Press, pp. 42–57.

Wallace, Rob; Liebman, Alex; Weisberger, David; Jonas, Tammi; Bergmann, Luke; Kock, Richard; Wallace, Rodrick (2020b), “The Origins of Industrial Agricultural Pathogens”, in Rob Wallace, Dead Epidemiologists: On the Origins of COVID-19, New York: Monthly Review Press, pp. 102–129.

Warden, Lisa (2020), “A Palate for Pestilence: Ominous Links Between COVID-19 and Industrial Animal Farming”, Sentient Media, 19 March. https://sentientmedia.org/ominous-links-between-covid-19-and-industrial-animal-farming/

Wassenaar, Tom; Gerber, Pierre J.; Verbung, Peter H.; Rosales, Mauricio; Ibrahim, Muhammad; Steinfeld, Henning (2007), “Projecting Land Use Changes in the Neotropics: The Geography of Pasture Expansion into Forest”, Global Environmental Change 17(1): 86–104.

Young, Iris Marion (2011), Responsibility for Justice. New York: Oxford University Press.

Zimmerman, Michael J. (2001). “Responsibility”, in Lawrence C. Becker, Charlotte B. Becker (eds.), Encyclopedia of Ethics (2nd ed.), New York, Abingdon: Routledge, pp. 1486–1492.