Targeted Killing with Drones? Old Arguments, New Technologies

Tamar Meisels

doi:10.2298/FID1801003M

Authors

Tamar Meisels Faculty of Social Sciences, Tel Aviv University

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.2298/FID1801003M

Keywords:

drons, targeted killing, justification, asymmetrical warfare, terrorism

Abstract

The question of how to contend with terrorism in keeping with our preexisting moral and legal commitments now challenges Europe as well as Israel and the United States: how do we apply Just War Theory and
International Law to asymmetrical warfare, specifically to our counter terrorism measures? What can the classic moral argument in Just and Unjust Wars teach us about contemporary targeted killings with drones?
I begin with a defense of targeted killing, arguing for the advantages of pin pointed attacks over any alternative measure available for combatting terrorism. Assuming the legitimacy of killing combatants in wartime, I argue, there is nothing wrong, and in fact much that is right, with targeting particular terrorists selected by name, as long as their assassinations can be reasonably expected to reduce terrorist hostilities rather than increase it. Subsequently, I offer some further thoughts and comments on the use of remotely piloted aircrafts to carry out targeted killings, and address the various sources for discomfort with this practice identified by Michael Walzer and others.

References

Altman Andrew (2014), “Targeted Killing as an Alternative to War: The Problem of the Fair Distribution of Risk”, ELAC Annual Workshop.
Blum, Gabriella and Philip Heymann (2010), “Law and Policy of Targeted Killing”, Harvard National Security Journal (1) 145: 155–165.
Corn, Geoffrey (2009), “Back to the Future: De Facto Hostilities, Transnational Terrorism, and the purpose of the Law of Armed Conflict”, University of Pennsylvania Journal of International Law 30: 1345–1354.
Dershowitz, Alan (2009), “Israel’s Policy is Perfectly Proportionate”, The Wall Street Journal, 2 January.
Finkelstein, Claire, Jens David Ohlin and Andrew Altman (eds.) (2010), Targeted Killing – Law and Morality in an Asymmetrical World. New York: Oxford University Press, 2010.
Gross, Michael (2010), Moral Dilemmas of Modern War – Torture, Assassination, and Blackmail in an age of Asymmetric Conflict. New York: Cambridge University Press, 2010.
—. (2004), “Assassination: Killing in the Shadow of Self-Defense”, in Jones Irwin (ed.), War and Virtual War: The Challenges of Communities, Amsterdam: Rodopi, pp. 99–116.
—. (2003), “Fighting by Other Means in the Mid-East: A Critical Analysis of Israel’s Assassination Policy”, Political Studies 51: 350–368.
Gusterson, Hugh (2016), Drone – Remote Control Warfare. Cambridge, Mass: MIT Press, 2016.
Kahn, Paul (2002), “The Paradox of Riskless Warfare”, Philosophy & Public Policy Quarterly 22: 2–8.
HCJ 7015/02 (2002).
HCJ 769/02 (2005).
Heller, Kevin Jon (2013), “One Hell of a Killing Machine: Signature Strikes and International Law”, Journal of International Criminal Justice 11 (1): 89–119.
Living under Drones: Death, Injury, and Trauma to Civilians from US Drone Practices in Pakistan, International Human Rights and Conflict Resolution Clinic, Stanford Law School; Global Justice Clinic, NYU School of Law (September, 2012).
http://chrgj.org/wp-content/uploads/2012/10/Living-Under-Drones.pdf
McMahan, Jeff (2013), “Forward to Killing by Remote Control”, in Killing by Remote Control: The Ethics of an Unmanned Military, Oxford: Oxford University Press, pp. ix–xv.
Maxwell, Mark (2010), “Rebutting the Civilian Presumption: Playing Whack-A-Mole without a Mallet?”, in Targeted Killing – Law and Morality in an Asymmetrical World, pp. 30–59.
Statman, Daniel (2015), “Drones and Robots: On the Changing Practice of Warfare”, in Helen Frowe and Seth Lazar (eds.), Oxford Handbook of the Ethics of War. Oxford University Press, Online Handbooks. http://lecturers.haifa.ac.il/en/hcc/dstatman/Documents/Drones_and_Robots.pdf
—. (2014), “Drones, Robots and the Ethics of War”, (2014/1) Zebis Ethics and Armed Force – Controversies in Military Ethics and Security Policies 1 (e-journal), 41–45.
—. (2003a), “Targeted Killing”, Theoretical Inquiries in Law 5: 179–198.
—. (2003b), “The Morality of Assassination: A Response to Gross”, Political Studies 51: 350–368.
Strawser, Bradley Jay (ed.) (2013), Killing by Remote Control – The Ethics of an Unmanned Military. New York: Oxford University Press.
—. (2010), “Moral Predators: The Duty to Employ Uninhabited Aerial Vehicles”, 9 Journal of Military Ethics 9, 342–368.
Waldron, Jeremy (2015), “Death Squads and Death Lists: Targeted Killing and the Character of the State”, New York University Public Law and Legal Theory Working Papers 519: 1–36. http://lsr.nellco.org/nyu_plltwp/519/
—. (2011), “Targeted Killing”, London Review of Books, 7 May.
Walzer, Michael and Avishai Margalit (2009): “Israel: Civilians & Combatants”, The New York Review of Books, May 14.
Walzer, Michael (2016), “Just & Unjust Targeted Killing & Drone Warfare”, Daedalus 145 (4): 12–24.
—. (2013), “Targeted Killing and Drone Warfare”, Dissent, January 11.
—. (1977), Just and Unjust Wars. New York: Basic Books.