The Spectres of the Yugoslav Wars: Minorities’ Response to State Disintegration

Aleksandar Pavlović

doi:10.2298/FID2304653P

Authors

Aleksandar Pavlović Institute for Philosophy and Social Theory

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.2298/FID2304653P

Keywords:

Yugoslavia, Yugoslav wars, Minorities, Serbs, Croats, Albanians, Bosniaks

Abstract

This article discusses minorities’ responses to conflicts in post-1989 Eastern Europe that focuses on them embracing violence to cede from their original state and join their motherland or gain independence. The discussion focuses on the actions of minorities in the contested areas in the former Yugoslavia at the peak of the country’s 1990s crisis, described as a drive towards ethnic self-determination. Faced with political crisis, disintegration and/or oppression, most ethnic groups opted for confrontation, secession and armed revolt/resistance with maximalist independence claims instead of cooperation, integration or compromise. Furthermore, I discuss some possible implications of the grim Yugoslav experience. As I argue, to understand why minorities reverted to war in the former Yugoslavia and beyond, we perhaps need to recognize that post-1989 revolutions in Eastern Europe were predominantly the expressions of nationalist revolt and not democratic revolutions. In conclusion, I discuss some general conditions required for a minority to rise to arms, following Jenne’s theory that stresses the role of external patrons in spurring internal conflicts. I emphasize this synergy of ethnic nationalism, external support by the kin state and/or international actors and minority’s oppression as decisive for the eruption of ever-present antagonisms into a larger conflict and war.

References

Arday, Lajos (1996), “Hungarians in Serb-Yugoslav Vojvodina since 1944”, Nationalities Papers 24 (3): 467–482.

Beretka, Katinka (2019), “Evolution of the Autonomy Ambitions of Vojvodina Hungarians – Constitution And Activity of The Hungarian Minority Council in Serbia”, Hungarian Review 10 (3).

Bieber, Florian; Galijaš, Armina; Archer, Rory (2016), Debating the End of Yugoslavia, Oxton/New York: Routledge.

Bieber, Florian; Daskalovski, Židas (eds.) (2003), Understanding the War in Kosovo, London: Frank Cass.

Bookman, Milica (1994), “War and Peace: The Divergent Breakups of Yugoslavia and Czechoslovakia”, Journal of Peace Research 31 (2), 175–187. http://www.jstor.org/ stable/425031

Bunce, Valerie (1999), “Peaceful versus Violent State Dismemberment: A Comparison of the Soviet Union, Yugoslavia, and Czechoslovakia”, Politics & Society 27 (2), 217–237. https://doi.org/10.1177/0032329299027002003

Ćeriman, Jelena; Pavlović, Aleksandar (2020), “Beyond the Territory Principle: Non-territorial Approach to the Kosovo Question(s)”, Philosophy and Society 31 (3): 277–448.

Chronology for Sandzak Muslims in Yugoslavia (2004), Minorities at Risk Project, available at: https://www.refworld.org/docid/469f38f61e.html (accessed 19 October 2023)

Fukuyama, Francis (1992), The End of History and the Last Men, New York: The Free Press.

Hozić, Aida; Subotić, Jelena; Vučetić, Srđan (2020), “Yugosplaining the World”, The Disorder of Things, 2 July, available at https://thedisorderofthings. com/2020/07/02/yugosplainingthe-world-%E2%80%AF/ (accessed 19 October 2023)

ICTY Indictment to Milan Martić (2002), https://www.icty.org/x/cases/martic/ind/ en/mar-ai021218e.htm (accessed 19 April 2023)

Jenne, Erin K. (2007), “Ethnic Bargaining in the Balkans: Secessionist Kosovo versus integrationist Vojvodina”, in Erin K. Jenne, Ethnic Bargaining: The Paradox of Minority Empowerment, Cornell University Press, pp. 159–183.

Kennedy, Thomas (2020), “Using Czechoslovakia and Yugoslavia to Predict the Outcome of the Dissolution of States: Factors that Lead to Internal Conflict and Civil War”, Open Political Science 3 (1): 1–10. https://doi.org/10.1515/ openps-2020-0001

Ker-Lindsay, James (2013), “Preventing the Emergence of Self-Determination as a Norm of Secession: An Assessment of the Kosovo ‘Unique Case’ Argument”, Europe-Asia Studies 65: 837–856.

Krastev, Ivan; Holmes, Stephen (2019), The Light that Failed: Why the West Is Losing the Fight for Democracy, New York: Pegasus Books.

Mehmeti, Leandrit; Radeljić, Branislav (eds.) (2016), Kosovo and Serbia: Contested Opinions and Shared Consequences, Pittsburgh: University of Pittsburgh Press.

Milanović, Branko (2022), “On Import Substitution, Fukuyama, Eternal Growth and More”, Global Inequality and More 3.0, https://branko2f7.substack.com/p/on- import-substitution-fukuyama-eternal (accessed 19 April 2023)

Pavlović, Aleksandar (2021), “Autonomy or Independence: Minority Arrangements for Vojvodina Hungarians and Kosovo Albanians in Serbia during and after the Yugoslav Period”, in Balázs Vizi, Balázs Dobos, Natalija Shikova (eds.), Non- Territorial Autonomy as an Instrument for Effective Participation of Minorities, Centre for Social Sciences, Budapest & University American College Skopje, pp. 139–157, https://entan.org/wp-content/uploads/2021/10/ENTAN-volume_ Non-Territorial-Autonomy-as-an-Instrument-for-Effective-Participation-of- Minorities_2021_final.pdf

Pavlović, Aleksandar; Pudar Draško, Gazela; Lončar, Jelena (2021), “A Battle for Sovereignty: Who Owns Cultural Heritage in Kosovo?”, Southeastern Europe 45 (3): 361–386.

Pavlović, Momčilo (2009), “Kosovo under Autonomy, 1974-1990”, in Charles Ingrao, Thomas A. Emmett (eds.), Confronting The Yugoslav Controversies: A Scholars’ Initiative, West Lafayette (Indiana): Purdue University Press, pp. 48–80.

Ramet, Sabrina P. (2005), Thinking about Yugoslavia: Scholarly Debates about the Yugoslav Breakup and the Wars in Bosnia and Kosovo, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Republički zavod za statistiku (1991), Stanovništvo prema nacionalnoj pripadnosti. Popis 1991. https://www.stat.gov.rs/sr-latn/oblasti/popis/prethodni-popisi/ popisni-podaci-eksel-tabele/

Silber, Laura; Little, Allan (1996), The Death of Yugoslavia, London: Penguin. Smith, David J.; Semenyshyn, Mariana (2016), “Territorial–administrative Decentralisation and Ethno-cultural Diversity in Ukraine: Addressing Hungarian Autonomy Claims in Zakarpattya”, ECMI Working Paper #95. European Centre for Minority Issues. https://www.ecmi.de/fileadmin/ redakteure/publications/pdf/Working_Paper_95.pdf

Várady, Tibor (1997), “Minorities, Majorities, Law, and Ethnicity: Reflections of the Yugoslav Case”, Human Rights Quarterly 1 (1997): 9–54.